/Compare

    Compare Solutions

    Side-by-side comparison of 3 solutions

    Scroll to compare
    Progressive Commercial logo

    Progressive Commercial Trucking Insurance

    Insurance Services
    Mayfield Heights, OH10001+
    Zurich North America logo

    Zurich Transportation Insurance

    Insurance Services
    Schaumburg, IL10000+
    AmTrust Financial Services, Inc. logo

    AmTrust Commercial Property & Casualty Insurance

    Insurance Services
    New York, NY5000+
    Overview
    Progressive Commercial Trucking Insurance

    Number one commercial truck insurer with Smart Haul telematics discount program

    Zurich Transportation Insurance

    Global transportation insurance with multinational and environmental coverage programs.

    AmTrust Commercial Property & Casualty Insurance

    Commercial property & casualty and workers’ compensation coverage for small businesses, supported by risk management resources and claims expertise.

    Quick Facts
    Founded
    1937
    1912
    1998
    Location
    Mayfield Heights, OH
    Schaumburg, IL
    New York, NY
    Employees
    10001+
    10000+
    5000+
    Features
    10 max
    Progressive Commercial Trucking Insurance
    8 features
    • Auto Liability
    • Physical Damage
    • Cargo Coverage
    • Smart Haul Program
    • Snapshot ProView
    • Online Quotes
    • +2 more features
    Zurich Transportation Insurance
    10 features
    • Motor truck cargo insurance
    • Primary liability coverage up to $1M
    • Environmental transportation program
    • Physical damage insurance
    • Excess liability coverage
    • Multinational logistics solutions
    • +4 more features
    AmTrust Commercial Property & Casualty Insurance
    10 features
    • Commercial auto liability ($300K-$1M CSL)
    • Physical damage for owned/leased vehicles
    • Motor truck cargo up to $250K
    • Small fleet coverage (<20 units)
    • Large commercial fleet programs
    • Local and intermediate radius operations
    • +4 more features
    Capabilities
    Progressive Commercial Trucking Insurance
    1 capabilities
    Carrier / Fleet Insurance Services
    Zurich Transportation Insurance
    2 capabilities
    Carrier / Fleet Insurance Services
    Cargo / Shipper Insurance Services
    AmTrust Commercial Property & Casualty Insurance
    1 capabilities
    Carrier / Fleet Insurance Services
    Target Audience
    Progressive Commercial Trucking Insurance
    Buyer Types
    Carrier
    Private Fleets
    Company Sizes
    SMB
    Mid-Market
    Enterprise
    Zurich Transportation Insurance
    Buyer Types
    Carrier
    3PL
    Freight Forwarder
    Manufacturers and Shippers
    Company Sizes
    Mid-Market
    Enterprise
    AmTrust Commercial Property & Casualty Insurance
    Buyer Types
    Carrier
    Private Fleets
    Company Sizes
    SMB
    Mid-Market
    Enterprise
    Integrations
    6 max
    Progressive Commercial Trucking Insurance
    5 integrations
    Geotab
    Motive
    Omnitracs
    ELD Systems
    FMCSA
    Zurich Transportation Insurance
    6 integrations
    Vindati
    SAP ERP
    Oracle ERP
    Risk management platforms
    Claims management systems
    Fleet Telematics
    AmTrust Commercial Property & Casualty Insurance
    2 integrations
    Agent networks
    Safety platforms

    How to compare supply chain software side by side

    Comparing two or more vendors on the same criteria is the fastest way to cut through marketing claims. Look beyond feature checklists — pricing model, integration depth, support quality, and roadmap fit usually matter more than any single feature.

    Key features

    • Match the use case

      A tool that wins for a 5-truck carrier may lose for a 500-truck 3PL. Compare within your size and segment.

    • Compare total cost

      Look at implementation, integrations, training, and per-user fees — not just the headline subscription.

    • Check integration depth

      A native integration with your TMS or ERP is worth more than a generic API.

    • Test support quality

      Ask for response time SLAs and talk to a current customer your size before you pick.

    • Read independent reviews

      Cross-check vendor claims with reviews from buyers in your industry, not just the vendor's case studies.

    • Ask about roadmap

      Pick a vendor that is investing in the areas you care about for the next 2–3 years.

    Frequently asked questions

    Start with your category page on SupplyWolf, filter by company size and segment, and pick the 2–4 vendors that match your profile. Avoid comparing across very different segments.

    That is fine for adjacent tools (e.g., TMS vs. visibility platform), but the comparison should focus on the overlap. Be explicit about what each tool does and does not do.

    Yes. Use the Create RFP button on this page to turn your shortlist into a structured RFP that vendors respond to in the same format.

    Ready to get vendor responses?

    Turn your shortlist into a structured RFP and get apples-to-apples answers in days.