← Back to alternatives

GEP SMART Alternatives to Evaluate

Compare alternatives to GEP SMART against the same Procurement / Freight Orchestration Platforms workflows and requirements. Confirm current product scope and pricing directly with each provider.

Starting with GEP SMART, compare each option against the same requirements.

Options to compare

Coupa Supply Chain Design

  • Features: Network Optimization, Sourcing Optimization, Scenario Planning, Inventory Optimization, Carbon Scope 1/2/3, App Studio, Multi-Echelon Planning, Tariff Impact Analysis
  • Integrations: SAP, SAP S/4HANA, SAP ECC, Oracle Cloud ERP, Oracle E-Business Suite, Oracle Fusion, NetSuite, Microsoft Dynamics 365, Workday, Sage Intacct, JD Edwards
  • Best suited for: Not listed
  • Core strengths: Not listed

Flexport Procurement

Flexport Procurement is an end-to-end supply chain platform integrating order management with global logistics. Features centralized PO control, real-time supplier collaboration, SKU-level tracking, and automated booking. Includes Convoy trucking technology with ML-powered carrier risk monitoring. Customers save 4 hours/week on average.

  • Features: Order Management, Supplier Collaboration, SKU Tracking, Automated Booking, Customs & Compliance, Flexport Capital, Carbon Neutrality, Custom Reporting
  • Integrations: ERP Systems, WMS, API integration, Mobile Apps
  • Best suited for: Not listed
  • Core strengths: Not listed

GoodShip

GoodShip is an AI-powered freight orchestration and procurement platform built for enterprise shippers managing complex, high-volume transportation spend. The platform combines an AI Transportation Analyst ('Laney') for instant data-driven answers, an AI-powered award optimizer for bid analysis, embedded market rate benchmarking (DAT, TruckStop, FreightWaves SONAR), carrier scorecards with a self-service portal, in-app collaboration messaging, and RFP performance monitoring. Designed for rapid deployment with a 4-week implementation timeline, GoodShip delivers measurable results: 3–5% reduction in freight spend to market and a 20% decrease in late loads. Recognized by FreightWaves FreightTech 25 and FreightTech 100.

  • Features: AI Award Optimizer, AI Transportation Analyst (Laney), Embedded Market Rate Benchmarking, DAT/TruckStop/SONAR Integration, Carrier Scorecards & Self-Service Portal, RFP & Bid Management, In-App Collaboration Messaging, Performance-to-Budget Reporting, Late Load Dispute Resolution, Mini-Bid to Annual RFP Support, TMS Integration (Princeton TMX)
  • Integrations: Not listed
  • Best suited for: Not listed
  • Core strengths: Not listed

Infios Sourcing

Infios is a multimodal TMS with advanced sourcing optimization. Features market-driven spot buying, load optimization, automated carrier selection based on scorecards, and 80% faster invoice processing. Ranked #3 TMS on SelectHub. Industry-leading TMS platform.

  • Features: Spot Buying, Load Optimizer, Carrier Scorecards, Multi-Currency Rating, Freight Audit, Control Tower, AES/CBP Integration
  • Integrations: SAP, Oracle, Microsoft Dynamics, NetSuite, WMS, EDI
  • Best suited for: Not listed
  • Core strengths: Not listed

Keelvar

Keelvar is an AI-native strategic sourcing platform featuring Kai, an AI sourcing agent that automates up to 100% of sourcing processes. Enables natural language RFP creation, autonomous supplier selection, and intelligent bid evaluation. Used by Siemens, Coca-Cola, Samsung, and Mars. 71% of events managed by AI agents.

  • Features: AI Sourcing Agent (Kai), Autonomous Sourcing, Natural Language RFP, Sourcing Optimizer, Predictive Analytics, Workflow Builder, Outlier Detection
  • Integrations: ERP Systems, API integration, Procurement Suites
  • Best suited for: Not listed
  • Core strengths: Not listed

Loadsmart Freight Platform

Loadsmart's freight platform connects planning, procurement, execution, and settlement workflows. Its current site describes automated tendering against routing-guide rules, freight exception handling, and support from Loadsmart Freight Experts. ShipperGuide is offered separately as its TMS.

  • Features: Freight planning and procurement workflows, Routing-guide tendering against configured rules and rate benchmarks, Freight execution and exception handling with Freight Experts, Settlement and payment workflows, Connections to scheduling, gate, yard, and dock solutions
  • Integrations: Not listed
  • Best suited for: Not listed
  • Core strengths: Not listed

Navisphere RFP

C.H. Robinson Navisphere is a global TMS platform used by 200,000+ companies featuring Procure IQ, a data-driven RFP strategy tool. Analyzes lanes against 500K+ shippers and carriers database. Beta showed 60% of routes achieve better savings outside annual RFP. Access to 66,000+ carriers.

  • Features: Procure IQ, Navisphere Insight, Market Rate IQ, Multi-Provider Management, Customs Analytics, Mobile Apps
  • Integrations: ERP Systems, Microsoft Azure IoT, TMS integration, API
  • Best suited for: Not listed
  • Core strengths: Not listed

Oracle Transportation Sourcing

Oracle Transportation Sourcing is a comprehensive freight procurement module within Oracle Transportation Management (OTM). The platform automates the entire procurement lifecycle including carrier selection, bidding, and rate negotiation using historical shipment data for intelligent bid projects. Awarded rates automatically flow into OTM for operational use with seamless integration to freight payment. The structured sourcing process supports bid rounds with carrier response templates and scenario analysis.

  • Features: Automated freight procurement lifecycle, Historical data-driven bidding, Carrier response templates, Multi-round bid management, Scenario analysis and solving, Awarded rates auto-execution, Rate maintenance, Multi-mode support, TMS integration, Cloud and on-premise deployment
  • Integrations: Oracle Fusion Cloud ERP, Oracle Cloud SCM, Oracle TMS, SAP ERP, Carrier Bid Networks, Rate Benchmarking Data, JD Edwards
  • Best suited for: Not listed
  • Core strengths: Not listed

project44 Procurement

Movement by project44 is a Decision Intelligence Platform providing end-to-end supply chain visibility and freight procurement. Features AI agents for autonomous bookings, multi-modal tracking (ocean, air, rail, FTL, LTL), GLEC-accredited Scope 3 emissions reporting, and AI-powered ETAs more accurate than carrier estimates.

  • Features: Multi-Modal Tracking, AI-Powered ETAs, Order Visibility, AI Agents, Freight Audit, GHG Emissions Tracking, Port Intelligence
  • Integrations: project44 Visibility Platform, SAP Ariba, Carrier Networks, Rate Benchmarking Data, REST APIs, EDI connectivity
  • Best suited for: Not listed
  • Core strengths: Not listed

SAP Ariba Logistics Procurement

SAP Ariba provides enterprise-grade procurement for transportation and logistics services as part of the SAP Business Network ecosystem. The platform enables freight collaboration with carriers and 3PLs through cXML-based transport requests and confirmations. The 2024 Next-Gen platform features Joule AI copilot for natural language assistance and upcoming Bid Analysis Agent for automated supplier comparison. Real-time shipment tracking provides global visibility while Scope 3 emissions tracking supports sustainability goals. Deep integration with SAP Transportation Management and S/4HANA.

  • Features: Freight collaboration with carriers/3PLs, cXML transport transactions, Joule AI copilot, Bid Analysis Agent (2025), Real-time shipment tracking, Scope 3 emissions tracking, Freight dispute resolution, Supplier risk management, Dynamic discounting, Contract workspace
  • Integrations: SAP Transportation Management, SAP S/4HANA, SAP ERP, SAP Business Network, SAP Logistics Management
  • Best suited for: Not listed
  • Core strengths: Not listed

Trimble Transporeon Freight Sourcing Hub

Transporeon Freight Sourcing Hub provides digital freight procurement across all modes with access to 180,000+ carriers. The platform features AI-native Autonomous Procurement that predicts optimal spot rates per carrier using machine learning and behavioral science, cutting transaction costs by up to 19%. Strategic tendering supports RFQs for spot, seasonal, and long-term contracts with automated calculations and rate comparisons. Real-time market intelligence and benchmarking enable confident sourcing decisions. Over 10,000 RFQs issued annually through the platform.

  • Features: AI-native Autonomous Procurement, ML-powered spot rate prediction, 180,000+ carrier network, Multi-mode sourcing (road, air, ocean, rail), One-click freight tenders, Automated bid analysis, Real-time market intelligence, 50,000+ carrier profiles database, Strategic benchmarking, Rate management integration
  • Integrations: Not listed
  • Best suited for: Not listed
  • Core strengths: Not listed

What to compare

  • Procurement / Freight Orchestration Platforms workflow and operating requirements
  • Listed features, integrations, and data coverage
  • Implementation ownership, support, and rollout requirements
  • Data access, portability, governance, and contract assumptions

Procurement / Freight Orchestration Platforms buying guidance

At a glance: Freight procurement software organizes some part of transportation sourcing: defining demand, requesting offers, comparing responses, evaluating award choices or maintaining selected rates. It is distinct from day-to-day shipment execution, although sourcing, TMS and ERP products may exchange data. Freightos Procure; Transportation Sourcing Overview; Features of SAP Transportation Management

Common workflows

  • Carrier RFQ or tender: Define lanes, invite carriers, collect comparable offers and document negotiation and award steps. Freightos describes RFQ distribution, standardized responses and scenario analysis; this is a provider description, not an independent cycle-time or savings result. Freightos Procure
  • Shipment-history-led sourcing: Use historical shipment information and buyer-defined constraints to prepare a lane event, compare awards and maintain rates. Oracle documents shipment history, bid processing, award scenarios and rate upload in Transportation Sourcing; validate the precise module and integration configuration. Transportation Sourcing Overview
  • Quote rounds and rate determination: Transportation systems may support quote preparation, provider exchanges and rate determination as part of broader operations. SAP describes quotation rounds and automated rate determination; this does not establish product equivalence with dedicated sourcing or a buyer's exact feature entitlement. Features of SAP Transportation Management

Questions to ask providers

  • Is the need an annual or seasonal RFP, a mini-bid, spot buying, contract-rate maintenance, network planning or shipment execution?
  • Which lanes, modes, volumes, equipment, service criteria and shipment history are in the proposed event?
  • How are non-comparable bids, missing surcharges, incomplete responses and late offers handled?
  • Who can negotiate, recommend an award, approve it and publish the selected rate?
  • How are cost, service, capacity, coverage and other configured objectives weighted and inspected?
  • Which exact TMS/ERP versions, rate fields, data directions and error paths are included?
  • What data rights, pricing, implementation services and ongoing support are stated in the contract?
  • How will the buyer measure results against a documented baseline without treating vendor claims as forecasts?

Frequently asked questions

Is freight procurement software the same as a TMS?

No. Procurement focuses on sourcing offers and decisions; a TMS may manage transportation planning and execution. Oracle says its sourcing product can be used with or without the rest of Oracle Transportation Management. Transportation Sourcing Overview

Should the lowest bid always win?

No universal award rule applies. Oracle describes evaluating multiple scenarios based on cost, service and other factors. Buyers should define and approve their own criteria. Transportation Sourcing Overview

What information should we prepare for a demo?

Prepare representative lanes, shipment history, constraints, service criteria, surcharges, bid formats and approval rules; ask to test incomplete responses and exceptions. Freightos Procure; Transportation Sourcing Overview

Can procurement software guarantee savings?

No. Published vendor outcomes are not a forecast for a different buyer. Measure the same freight scope against a documented baseline and include service and execution results. Freightos Procure

Can awarded rates flow to a TMS?

Some product documentation describes rate transfer. Oracle documents rate upload to Oracle Transportation Management; verify fields, direction, configuration and commercial scope for your system. Transportation Sourcing Overview

Are procurement modules comparable across ERP and sourcing vendors?

Not by name alone. SAP describes quotation rounds and rate determination in Transportation Management; compare the actual bid, award, approval and integration functions in each proposal. Freightos Procure; Features of SAP Transportation Management

Sources (3)
  1. Freightos Procure — Freightos
  2. Transportation Sourcing Overview — Oracle
  3. Features of SAP Transportation Management — SAP

Profiles show selected details, not every product capability. Confirm current requirements and terms with each provider.

Pricing guides · Common comparisons · Build a custom comparison